Short URLs, trust and security
A recent episode of the For Immediate Release podcast — I believe it was show 486 — included a discussion about worms on Twitter and the connection with the (in)security of shortened URLs shared online. As FIR co-host Shel Holtz alluded to, even if you trust the sender or sharer of a shortened URL, those links — which mask the destination with a simpler, shorter tinyurl.com or bit.ly address — are fraught with danger. Or, at least, potential danger.
This is something I’ve discussed more than once with my friend and local code wizard Garrick Van Buren. He’s built his own URL shortener, grv.me, that he uses to share stuff he creates. He’s done the same for MinnPost.com with its minnpo.st URL shortener, which the local news outfit uses to share its own stories on Twitter and the like.
Why? Trust. When you see a TinyURL, you have no idea what the link is going to point you to. Viruses, spyware, porn and all sorts of other unwanted or inappropriate stuff are just a click away. Sure, there are some tricks to help alleviate that problem, but what if you actually could trust a shortened URL?
That’s there grv.me and minnpo.st come in. Once you’re familiar with them — once their respective publishers introduce you to them — you can trust them as much as you trust their publishers. Because you know only Garrick can create grv.me URLs, there’s no virus at the other end. Coke, a client of ours, also created its own URL shortener — with trust being one factor and, I’m sure, the desire to control the technology rather than rely on someone else’s as another factor. (though we had nothing to do with the creation of this tool).
The need for safety and security online will not go away. Don’t worry: Smart people like Garrick will be here to help.
Photo courtesy of zach_manchester on Flickr
Related items
One concern I’ve had with custom URL shorteners is reliability. There are businesses who are in the business of making sure their shortener applications run 24×7 with real-time tracking. That’s tough for many businesses to replicate.
That being said, the trust factor carries some weight. The company I work for builds them in to make linking to search results more manageable, like this search for $1m+ homes in Kenwood: http://www.results.net/Search/16592
[...] Mike Keliher on Short URL Trust Today in URL Design by Garrick “When you see a TinyURL, you have no idea what the link is going to point you to. Viruses, spy… [...]
Twitter Comment
@mjkeliher thanks mike, here’s a non-bitly for you
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Twitter Comment
RT @mjkeliher: I’m sharing a link to my post about short URLs, trust … using an untrustworthy bit.ly link. Sue me. [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Twitter Comment
Using custom short URLs as a way to regain trust: [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Twitter Comment
@ikepigott 1) didn’t you spoof a firefox plugin for this very thing a year ago? 2) thanks for that link not going to lemonparty.org
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Twitter Comment
@jacobpigott – No, read the article.
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Minnesota Monday – Communications Bloggers Posts From Last Week…
Interesting posts from Minnesota commmunications bloggers for the week ending 10/10/09.
……